Scotland on Sunday // The Best Thing That Can Happen To a Croissant by Pablo Tusset
Sleazy sleuth sets out on mystery trail
Canongate, £10.99
By Andrew Ervin
IN HIS debut novel, Spanish author Pablo Tusset takes a long hard look at the mystery novel tradition, and gives it both the thumbs-up and the middle finger.
This is a whodunnit for people who generally cannot stand whodunnits. You know the basic formula: a crime gets committed early on and a world-weary sleuth follows a trail of blindingly obvious clues, finds a bit of romance along the way and eventually uncovers a terrible secret before saving the day.
But Pablo Miralles makes an unlikely hero. He is fat, lazy, moody, gluttonous, horny and pretty much constantly drunk or high on hashish. "A detective’s job is never as easy as it looks," he tells us. "You have to ask the right questions, naturally, but you also have to know how to interpret the answers, and my syllogistic intelligence tends to be stymied by an excess of imagination, such that as soon as I arrive at the only possible answer to an enigma, I immediately think up another 25 possibilities that get in the way."
Thirtysomething Miralles is the son of a wealthy businessman. His younger, more straight-laced brother got himself mixed up with some shady characters and has gone missing. His investigative methods differ from those of, say, Sherlock Holmes. He counts hookers among his expenses.
"Seriously flabbergasted, I tried to make some sense out of my thoughts - I had been reading for three hours straight, smoking one joint after another, not to mention the Cardhu-and-aspirin breakfast. I reread, at random, some verses in an attempt to find the trap, but my English is exclusively contemporary, and as soon as something sounds vaguely like Laurence Olivier doing Hamlet, it’s instantly medieval to me."
As he closes in on his brother’s keepers, he enlists a few friends, including an "Irish metaphysic suffering from a severe hangover, a German techie and a Chinese philologist specialising in medieval English literature". With their help he unlocks a website containing a long poem supposedly written in the Middle Ages, which makes strange references to late-20th century linguistic theory. That site also has some connection to a strange building in Miralles’s neighbourhood - one that may or may not house a secret society.
One long virtuosic section takes place in a whorehouse after Miralles finds its number stored in his brother’s mobile phone. A hooker named Beatrice gives him a tour of the facility, which is laid out to mimic the structure of Dante’s Inferno. The activity becomes more explicit the further he descends underground.
Tusset effectively takes all the hackneyed tropes of the noir story and, with a bit of irony, philosophical introspection and sheer pluck, turns them into something hugely entertaining. As both homage and parody, this book may very well be in a position to help revitalise the mystery novel tradition.
Canongate, £10.99
By Andrew Ervin
IN HIS debut novel, Spanish author Pablo Tusset takes a long hard look at the mystery novel tradition, and gives it both the thumbs-up and the middle finger.
This is a whodunnit for people who generally cannot stand whodunnits. You know the basic formula: a crime gets committed early on and a world-weary sleuth follows a trail of blindingly obvious clues, finds a bit of romance along the way and eventually uncovers a terrible secret before saving the day.
But Pablo Miralles makes an unlikely hero. He is fat, lazy, moody, gluttonous, horny and pretty much constantly drunk or high on hashish. "A detective’s job is never as easy as it looks," he tells us. "You have to ask the right questions, naturally, but you also have to know how to interpret the answers, and my syllogistic intelligence tends to be stymied by an excess of imagination, such that as soon as I arrive at the only possible answer to an enigma, I immediately think up another 25 possibilities that get in the way."
Thirtysomething Miralles is the son of a wealthy businessman. His younger, more straight-laced brother got himself mixed up with some shady characters and has gone missing. His investigative methods differ from those of, say, Sherlock Holmes. He counts hookers among his expenses.
"Seriously flabbergasted, I tried to make some sense out of my thoughts - I had been reading for three hours straight, smoking one joint after another, not to mention the Cardhu-and-aspirin breakfast. I reread, at random, some verses in an attempt to find the trap, but my English is exclusively contemporary, and as soon as something sounds vaguely like Laurence Olivier doing Hamlet, it’s instantly medieval to me."
As he closes in on his brother’s keepers, he enlists a few friends, including an "Irish metaphysic suffering from a severe hangover, a German techie and a Chinese philologist specialising in medieval English literature". With their help he unlocks a website containing a long poem supposedly written in the Middle Ages, which makes strange references to late-20th century linguistic theory. That site also has some connection to a strange building in Miralles’s neighbourhood - one that may or may not house a secret society.
One long virtuosic section takes place in a whorehouse after Miralles finds its number stored in his brother’s mobile phone. A hooker named Beatrice gives him a tour of the facility, which is laid out to mimic the structure of Dante’s Inferno. The activity becomes more explicit the further he descends underground.
Tusset effectively takes all the hackneyed tropes of the noir story and, with a bit of irony, philosophical introspection and sheer pluck, turns them into something hugely entertaining. As both homage and parody, this book may very well be in a position to help revitalise the mystery novel tradition.

